Nine Discourses on Commodus, Part IX

Cy Twombly’s Dialogue with History and Gesture

Few artists have merged the raw energy of graffiti with the weight of classical history as seamlessly as Cy Twombly. Nine Discourses on Commodus, Part IX stands as a prime example of his ability to distill complex narratives into spontaneous, almost childlike marks. The work belongs to a series inspired by the Roman emperor Commodus, a figure notorious for his tyranny and megalomania. Twombly’s fascination with antiquity was not academic but visceral—he treated historical subjects as living, breathing forces that could be conjured through the physical act of drawing.

The canvas becomes a battleground where scribbles, smudges, and scrawled text collide. Unlike the polished surfaces of traditional history painting, Twombly’s approach feels immediate, as though the artist were channeling the chaos of Commodus’s reign in real time. The Museum of Modern Art has noted how Twombly’s work often blurs the line between writing and drawing, a duality that gives pieces like this one their distinctive tension. Here, the absence of a fixed year only heightens the sense that the discourse is ongoing, a fragment of a larger, unresolved conversation.

The Roman Series and Twombly’s Late Career

By the time Twombly embarked on the Nine Discourses on Commodus series, he had long abandoned the constraints of pure abstraction in favor of a more literary and historical approach. The 1960s and 1970s marked a period where he increasingly turned to mythology, poetry, and ancient history as source material. Commodus, the emperor who fancied himself a gladiator and renamed Rome after himself, provided Twombly with a perfect subject: a figure whose grandeur and grotesquery mirrored the contradictions of modern power.

What distinguishes this series from earlier works is its fragmented narrative structure. Each "discourse" functions as a standalone meditation, yet they collectively form a larger critique. The Tate has emphasized how Twombly’s later works often function as cycles, demanding engagement over time rather than instant comprehension. The scribbled text in Part IX—partially legible, partially obscured—invites viewers to lean in, to decipher, and ultimately to participate in the discourse themselves.

Twombly’s genius lies in his ability to make history feel urgent. The smudges and erasures in Part IX aren’t just formal devices; they’re evidence of a struggle—both the artist’s and Commodus’s—to impose order on chaos.

The Physicality of Memory

Surface and Erasure

The texture of Nine Discourses on Commodus, Part IX is as critical as its imagery. Twombly worked on unprimed canvas, allowing the paint to soak into the fabric and creating a matte, almost chalky surface. This choice amplifies the sense of antiquity—the marks appear not just applied but embedded, as if they’ve been there for centuries. The erasures, where pigment has been smudged or wiped away, suggest the passage of time and the instability of historical records.

Graphic Rhythm and Scale

At 30×40 cm, this print preserves the intimate scale of Twombly’s original works, which often demanded close viewing. The composition relies on a push-and-pull between dense clusters of marks and areas of relative emptiness. The scribbled lines—sometimes looping, sometimes jagged—create a rhythmic counterpoint to the smudged gray and white fields. This tension between gesture and void is characteristic of Twombly’s mature style, where absence becomes as expressive as presence.

Where to Hang Nine Discourses on Commodus, Part IX

This print’s monochromatic palette and dynamic marks make it surprisingly versatile. In a modern interior, it acts as a counterpoint to clean lines—try hanging it above a minimalist console table or in a grid with other Twombly works for a curated gallery effect. The 30×40 cm size works particularly well in smaller spaces: a study, a reading nook, or even a powder room where its intellectual intensity can be savored in solitude.

For color pairings, the smudged grays and whites complement deep blues, charcoal walls, or warm wood tones. Avoid overly bright backdrops, which can diminish the print’s meditative quality. The framed edges (included) provide a crisp contrast to the organic marks, making it appear as though the discourse is contained within its own boundary—yet still spilling beyond it.

More Works by Cy Twombly

Explore Twombly’s range, from mythological cycles to pure abstraction—each print framed to the same exacting standards.

Cy Twombly

Hero And Leandro A Painting In Four Parts Part III

View print

Cy Twombly

Untitled Part VIII

View print

Cy Twombly

Lepanto Part VI

View print

Cy Twombly

Quattro Stagioni I Estate

View print

You May Also Love

Surrealism

Salvador Dalí

Agnostic Symbol

View print

Abstract Expressionism

Helen Frankenthaler

Beach Scene

View print

American Realism

Winslow Homer

Sunlight On The Coast

View print